Skip to main content

Why Public Bins Can’t Work in Lagos.

Historically, walking through Lagos' urban centers would often involve encountering public waste bins at nearly every corner. These bins were strategically positioned with the noble purpose of accommodating transit waste, meant for discarded plastic bottles, snack wrappers from bus rides, or casual litter from a constantly moving population.

Currently, these public bins have nearly disappeared from our streets. This decline was not due to logistical failure by authorities, but rather a necessary retreat prompted by persistent abuse of their intended purpose. Under the current socio-behavioral and structural realities of Lagos, it is evident that public bins are fundamentally unviable. The following are the reasons:

1. The Conflation of Private and Public Waste: 

The basic tenet of waste management in Lagos is clear, every property must have its own waste disposal system. Whether one is a landlord, a tenant in a "face-me-I-face-you" dwelling, or a shop owner, the responsibility falls on them to arrange for proper waste disposal through licensed operators.

However, the introduction of public bins invariably leads property owners and tenants to repurpose these bins as their personal dumping sites to evade waste disposal fees paid to private sector operators. Consequently, bins designed for specific, manageable waste types become overwhelmed, often by dawn.

While Lagos law mandates private property owners to manage their waste independently, public bins inadvertently subsidize unlawful dumping, transforming transit solutions into neighborhood nuisances.

2. Financial Implications: 

A critical question that advocates for public bins tend to overlook is, who bears the cost when household waste is dumped into public bins? Waste disposal is not complimentary, it involves significant financial expenditure—from fuel costs for collection vehicles to wages for sanitation personnel. The Lagos waste management framework relies heavily on a Private Sector Participant (PSP) model, where citizens remit a fee based on the waste generated.

Economic Loophole: 

When households clandestinely dispose of their weekly refuse into public bins, they benefit from a service they have not financially supported. This practice deprives the waste management system of essential revenue, creating a deficit that municipal budgets cannot sustain indefinitely. A system providing public bins for minor transit waste but exploited for large-scale residential dumping is inherently unsustainable.

Proposed Strategic Approach:

Recognizing that Western models of street-side public bins are incompatible with Lagos’ socio-economic structure is imperative. To achieve a cleaner city, the focus must shift from deploying public bins to enforcing existing laws and promoting behavioral change.

Enforce Property Penalties: Authorities must rigorously implement laws requiring all property owners to register with PSP and maintain functional internal waste bins. Non-compliance should attract severe penalties.

Commercial Accountability: Food outlets, markets, and shopping centers should be held accountable for waste within a designated radius of their premises. Littering in these vicinities should incur fines payable by the responsible businesses.

Cultivating a "Carry Your Trash" Culture: Citizens should be habituated to retain their waste until they reach a proper disposal point, be it a private residence, office, or authorized collection site. Just as individuals can carry an empty bottle after consuming water, they should similarly hold onto their waste until proper disposal.

In conclusion, the absence of public bins in Lagos does not signify failure but an acknowledgment of the prevailing reality. These bins failed because they became focal points for illegal dumping, overburdening the system and draining resources essential for the city’s functioning.

Lagos inhabitants do not require additional public bins to misuse, instead, adherence to existing regulations must be reinforced. A cleaner Lagos begins with society’s collective responsibility to refrain from seeking public receptacles as a cover for private waste disposal obligations.

By: Sanni Gbenga Ibrahim
Managing Editor & Lead Investigator
Lagos Waste Reporter 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Air pollution is literally rewriting our DNA. New research links dirty air to the same cancer mutations found in smokers.

Air pollution can cause DNA mutations that have been linked to lung cancer, according to new research showing strong connections between polluted air and the same genetic changes often seen in smokers.  Scientists analyzed the cancer genomes of 871 non-smokers with lung cancer from four continents and found a clear pattern. People living in areas with high levels of air pollution had more mutations in key genes tied to lung cancer, namely TP53 and EGFR, and were nearly four times more likely to show the SBS4 mutation, a known result of exposure to tobacco smoke. These mutations were far less common in non-smokers from cleaner regions. The study also uncovered a new mutational signature, SBS40a, present in 28% of non-smokers but absent in smokers, with no clear environmental cause identified. The research compared these non-smoker genomes with 345 smoker genomes to show both shared and unique patterns.  Secondhand smoke was linked to only a small increase in these g...
Post a Comment
Read more

THE LAGOS STATE GOVERNMENT IS IMPLEMENTING STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL INITIATIVES TO TACKLE WASTE MANAGEMENT ISSUES

...As the Environment Commissioner Conducts a Tour of Major Dumpsites The Lagos State Government publicly announced over the weekend its commitment to adopting strategic initiatives aimed at improving waste disposal and waste management practices. Following a tour of the primary dumpsites at Olusosun and Soluos 3, Mr. Tokunbo Wahab, the Commissioner for Environment and Water Resources, stated to the media that the government remains steadfast in its resolve to provide Lagosians with a sustainable and operational environment. Wahab indicated that within the upcoming 18 months, the state plans to decommission the Olusosun and Soluos 3 landfills. These sites will be transformed into contemporary Transfer Loading Stations, where waste will be sorted, compacted, and redirected for recycling and resource recovery. He noted that the Governor and the State Executive Council have regularly discussed waste-related issues, with particular attention given to the conditions at Olusosun ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Lagos Government seals Oko Oba Abattoir over unhygienic practices

Lagos State Government on Thursday announced the shutdown of the Oko-Oba abattoir over unsanitary activities, waste mismanagement and unhygienic handling of animal products. This directive was given by the Commissioner for the Environment and Water Resources, Mr. Tokunbo Wahab after an extensive inspection tour with the media to Oko-Oba the Abattoir at Oko-Oba in Agege informing that the Ministry received a petition from the Ministry of Agriculture to intervene as regards various Environmental and health infractions going on at the abattoir. According to him,  “What was witnessed at the abattoir today is heart-wrenching; the operators have defied and chosen to take laws into their hands as they slaughter animals and discharge the Waste into public drainage system with impunity and this is totally unacceptable.” Wahab said that upon the visitation to the abattoir, it was observed that the operators discharge all animal wastes into the public drainage channels leading to ...
Post a Comment
Read more